Spaceflight Now





Engineers continue shuttle heat shield assessment
BY WILLIAM HARWOOD
STORY WRITTEN FOR CBS NEWS "SPACE PLACE" & USED WITH PERMISSION
Posted: May 19, 2011


Bookmark and Share

KENNEDY SPACE CENTER, FL--Engineers have eliminated one of three damage sites on the shuttle Endeavour's heat shield tiles as an area of concern and a second may be dismissed and deemed safe for re-entry as is by Friday, a senior manager said Thursday. But one damage site on the shuttle's belly may require an additional, "focused," inspection Saturday to make sure repairs are not needed.


The two yellow boxes are the damage sites not yet cleared by analysts. Credit: NASA
 
LeRoy Cain, chairman of NASA's Mission Management Team, made it clear during a status briefing Thursday that he was not overly concerned by the damage to Endeavour's heat shield tiles, saying the primary area of interest was very similar to a tile gouge seen during a 2007 mission by Endeavour. In that case, a focused inspection was carried out and engineers determined, correctly as it turned out, that the shuttle could safely re-enter without the need for any repairs.

Addressing the "worry factor" for Endeavour's current mission, Cain said "when I was here yesterday, I talked about the fact that I am not concerned about the damage that we're seeing here, it's certainly not alarming. And the team is not concerned about it. My confidence is largely derived from the fact that we have a very good process for dispositioning these things, we know exactly how to go assess them, we've gotten better and better at it and we know that our models are doing nothing but improving as time goes on and we get more experience.

"In the event that we do come up to a point in our assessment where we feel like we need to get some more data, we know how to go do that, i.e., focused inspection, which we're talking about doing now. ... And then when it comes right down to it, if focused inspection and the analysis of the data from focused inspection determine we didn't have the kind of margins here that we wanted to have, then we do have some options to go do some repair."

In the wake of the 2003 Columbia disaster, NASA developed tile repair tools that range from STA-54, a thick material applied with a grease gun-like applicator that could be used by spacewalking astronauts to fill in a tile gouge, to a heat-resistant overlay that could be bolted in place over a larger damage site.

"But that's really about as far as I want to take this discussion because I feel pretty confident if, in fact, we're not able to clear it by the morning, when we get the focused inspection data we'll be able to clear this problem and not have to do anything. But having said that, we're going to go do whatever is necessary and we're going to follow the data all the way along."

During Endeavour's approach to the International Space Station Wednesday, commander Mark Kelly guided the ship through a computer-assisted back-flip maneuver to expose the shuttle's belly to the lab complex. Station astronauts Catherine Coleman, Paolo Nespoli and Expedition 27 commander Dmitry Kondratyev, photographed the shuttle's heat shield with powerful telephoto lenses to help engineers look for any signs of damage.

The photographs showed seven damage sites under the right wing running in a rough line from the right-side main landing gear door to an aft elevon, or wing flap. As of Wednesday, four of the seven sites had been ruled safe for entry as is and by Thursday, one of the remaining sites was eliminated, leaving just two areas of concern.

One of those, a gouge running across the hingeline of Eneavour's right-side inboard elevon, may be eliminated by Friday, Cain said. The other site, located between the right main landing gear door and an external tank liquid oxygen feel line port, may be more difficult to assess without a focused inspection to help determine the depth of the gouge.

The damage site measures 3.22 inches by 2.49 inches and is believed to be about seven tenths of an inch deep. The 2007 impact cited earlier by Cain resulted in a gouge measuring 3.48 inches by 2.31 inches with a depth of 1.12 inches. In that case, engineers eventually cleared Endeavour for re-entry as is and the shuttle completed a safe landing.


This particular ding could require the focused inspection Saturday. Credit: NASA
 
"In summary, we have some more work to do on a couple of these sites," Cain said. "Petty high confidence we're going to clear one of them, some possibility we're going to clear the other one. We have procedures built and timelines built and ready to go to the crew tomorrow morning whatever the scenario might be, for one or both of the sites. Or neither of them."

In a focused inspection, a camera on the end of the space station's robot arm would be used to carefully inspect a damage site of interest. If such an inspection is ordered for Endeavour, the astronauts would use a three-hour block of off-duty time early Saturday, starting around 2:26 a.m. EDT (GMT-4).


Spaceflight Now Plus
Additional coverage for subscribers:
VIDEO: AMAZING VIEWS INSIDE SOYUZ CAPSULE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP WALKTHROUGH OF EVA NO. 1 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: THURSDAY NIGHT FLIGHT DIRECTOR UPDATE PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 4 HIGHLIGHTS REEL PLAY
VIDEO: THURSDAY'S MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM UPDATE PLAY
VIDEO: THURSDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: INTERVIEWS WITH NPR, AP, REUTERS, FOX NEWS PLAY
VIDEO: MILES O'BRIEN MODERATES CREW INTERVIEW PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW CONGRATULATED BY AMS' LEADER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ALPHA MAGNETIC SPECTROMETER INSTALLED PLAY
VIDEO: AMS HANDED FROM SHUTTLE ARM TO STATION ARM PLAY
VIDEO: SPECTROMETER UNBERTHED FROM SHUTTLE BAY PLAY
VIDEO: WEDNESDAY NIGHT FLIGHT DIRECTOR UPDATE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: NARRATED DESCRIPTION OF AMS INSTALLATION PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ALPHA MAGNETIC SPECTROMETER ANIMATION PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 3 HIGHLIGHTS REEL PLAY
VIDEO: WEDNESDAY'S MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM UPDATE PLAY
VIDEO: EXPRESS LOGISTICS CARRIER NO. 3 INSTALLED PLAY
VIDEO: PALLET HANDED FROM SHUTTLE ARM TO STATION ARM PLAY
VIDEO: SPARE PARTS CARRIER UNBERTHED FROM SHUTTLE PLAY
VIDEO: A LOOK AT SPARE PARTS RIDING ON PALLET PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ANIMATED EXPLANATION OF ELC NO. 3 INSTALL PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: WEDNESDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR CREW WELCOMED ABOARD STATION PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: SHUTTLE AND STATION BROUGHT TO FIRM CONNECTION PLAY
VIDEO: DOCKING OF SHUTTLE TO STATION AS SEEN LIVE PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ARCS OUT IN FRONT OF SPACE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR PERFORMS THE 360-DEGREE BACKFLIP PLAY
VIDEO: NARRATED PREVIEW OF THE DOCKING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: GUIDED TOUR OF SHUTTLE'S PAYLOAD BAY PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS' FLIGHT DAY 2 HOME MOVIES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 2 HIGHLIGHTS REEL PLAY
VIDEO: TUESDAY'S MISSION MANAGEMENT TEAM UPDATE PLAY
VIDEO: INSPECTION BOOM UNBERTHED FROM SHUTTLE BAY PLAY
VIDEO: TUESDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PREVIEW OF FLIGHT DAY 2 PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS' FLIGHT DAY 1 HOME MOVIES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: FLIGHT DAY 1 HIGHLIGHTS REEL PLAY

VIDEO: THE FULL STS-134 LAUNCH EXPERIENCE PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ENDEAVOUR BLASTS OFF! PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS' VIEW OF JETTISONED FUEL TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: GO INSIDE MISSION CONTROL DURING LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: THE POST-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY
VIDEO: GIFFORDS' STAFF BRIEF REPORTERS PLAY

VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: VAB ROOF PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PRESS SITE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD PERIMETER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: BEACH TRACKER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PLAYALINDA BEACH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD FRONT CAMERA PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD CAMERA 070 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PAD CAMERA 071 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: UCS-23 TRACKER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH REPLAY: PATRICK AFB PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: CREW ARRIVES AT LAUNCH PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS LEAVE CREW QUARTERS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW FINISHES GETTING SUITED UP PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: BEAUTY SHOTS OF ENDEAVOUR ON THE PAD PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ROTATING SERVICE STRUCTURE RETRACTED PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: TIME-LAPSE OF SUNDAY'S GANTRY ROLLBACK PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ANOTHER TOWER TIME-LAPSE FROM PAD CAMERA PLAY

VIDEO: LOOK BACK AT ENDEAVOUR'S LAUNCH DELAY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: RECAP OF HEATER PROBLEM AND THE FIX PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: THE PRE-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY
VIDEO: COUNTDOWN STATUS AND WEATHER BRIEFING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS ARRIVE FOR SECOND COUNTDOWN PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR LAUNCH RESCHEDULED FOR MAY 16 PLAY
VIDEO: CHECKING ENDEAVOUR'S WIRING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: OLD ALCA-2 BOX OPENED UP FOR FORENSICS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: FAILED ALCA-2 BOX REMOVED FROM ENDEAVOUR PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: WORKING ON OLD AND NEW SWITCHBOXES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: LAUNCH OF ENDEAVOUR DELAYED FURTHER PLAY

VIDEO: PRESIDENT OBAMA ARRIVES AT THE CAPE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: TOUR OF ATLANTIS AND ASTRONAUT MEETING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: FIRST FAMILY DEPARTS AFTER VISIT PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: POST-SCRUB NEWS BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: LAUNCH DIRECTOR EXPLAINS SCRUB CALL PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: SCRUB DECLARED FOR APU NO. 1 HEATER GLITCH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS LEAVE QUARTERS BEFORE SCRUB PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW GETS SUITED UP FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: TIME-LAPSE OF PAD GANTRY RETRACTING PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR'S PRE-FLIGHT CAMPAIGN PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PAYLOADS' PRE-FLIGHT CAMPAIGN PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PREPARING ENDEAVOUR FUEL TANK FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: COUNTDOWN UPDATE AND WEATHER BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: THE PRE-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS ARRIVE AT LAUNCH SITE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: COUNTDOWN PREVIEW BRIEFING PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: GUIDED TOUR OF SPACE STATION PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR MISSION PREVIEW MOVIE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: GET TO KNOW ENDEAVOUR'S ASTRONAUTS PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH MARK KELLY PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH GREG JOHNSON PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH MIKE FINCKE PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH ROBERTO VITTORI PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH DREW FEUSTEL PLAY
VIDEO: PRE-FLIGHT INTERVIEW WITH GREG CHAMITOFF PLAY

VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR CLEARED FOR APRIL 29 LAUNCH PLAY

VIDEO: EVACUATION DRESS REHEARSAL PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS BOARD ENDEAVOUR PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: SUITING UP FOR PRACTICE COUNT PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: SHUTTLE INSPECTED FOR STORM DAMAGE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW TEST-DRIVES PAD ESCAPE VEHICLE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ASTRONAUT CHAT AT THE PRESS SITE PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CREW ARRIVES FOR PRACTICE COUNT PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PAYLOADS ARRIVE AT LAUNCH PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: CANISTER ROTATED UPRIGHT FOR PAD PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PALLET OF SPARE PARTS INTO CANISTER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: AMS PAYLOAD PUT INTO TRANSPORTER PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: SHUTTLE AND STATION PROGRAM BRIEFING PLAY
VIDEO: THE STS-134 MISSION OVERVIEW PRESENTATIONS PLAY
VIDEO: IN-DEPTH WITH ALPHA MAGNETIC SPECTROMETER PLAY
VIDEO: PREVIEW BRIEFING ON MISSION'S SPACEWALKS PLAY
VIDEO: THE ASTRONAUTS' PRE-FLIGHT NEWS BRIEFING PLAY

VIDEO: SUN RISES OVER THE LAUNCH PAD PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR ARRIVES ATOP PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ROLLOUT FROM VEHICLE ASSEMBLY BUILDING PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: HOISTING ENDEAVOUR TO TANK AND SRBS PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ORBITER GOES VERTICAL PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR LEAVES PROCESSING HANGAR PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: PAYLOAD MEDIA DAY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: THE ALPHA MAGNETIC SPECTROMETER PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PAYLOAD REMOVED FROM C-5 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: AMS ARRIVES FROM EUROPE PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: EXPRESS LOGISTICS CARRIER NO. 3 PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: HIGH-PRESSURE OXYGEN GAS TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: PUTTING STATION ANTENNA ON CARRIER PLAY | HI-DEF

VIDEO: TANK UNLOADED TO ASSEMBLY BUILDING PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: THE EXTERNAL FUEL TANK ARRIVES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: BOOSTER SEGMENT MOVED TO VAB PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: KENNEDY SPACE CENTER SRB CEREMONY PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ENDEAVOUR FITTED WITH MAIN ENGINES PLAY | HI-DEF
VIDEO: ORBITER TOWED OFF RUNWAY PLAY | HI-DEF

MORE: STS-134 VIDEO ARCHIVE
HDTV: HIGH-DEFINITION COVERAGE
SUBSCRIBE NOW



MISSION STATUS CENTER