A push to give NASA's Space Launch System a new name is garnering support from lawmakers, who have written into legislation provisions that would order NASA to rename the heavy-lift rocket through a competition among schoolchildren.
NASA zeroes in on root cause of shuttle tank cracks BY WILLIAM HARWOOD STORY WRITTEN FOR CBS NEWS "SPACE PLACE" & USED WITH PERMISSION Posted: January 11, 2011
Engineers believe they have zeroed in on the root cause of cracks in the shuttle Discovery's external tank, NASA officials said Tuesday. Installation of a relatively simple modification to the tops of the structural ribs, or stringers, where the ship's liquid oxygen tank is supported by a massive flange should resolve the problem once and for all, setting the stage for another launch attempt Feb. 24.
Engineers successfully duplicated a crack in a stringer using a test rig that subjected the U-shaped stringer to the forces experienced during fueling. Credit: NASA
"We're on the road to bringing this tank to a hundred percent," said shuttle Program Manager John Shannon. "It's been two months of very vigorous activity, it took a lot of investigation to piece the different components of how this could be happening together, but I'm very confident we've finally got this figured out and we have a fix that's easy to implement and will be 100 percent effective."
Discovery's late February launch window opens the day after the European Space Agency's unmanned Automated Transfer Vehicle, loaded with supplies and equipment, reaches the International Space Station. The ATV is scheduled for launch from French Guiana on Feb. 15. Mission managers initially planned a docking on Feb. 26, but ESA, NASA and Russian managers have agreed to aim for a docking Feb. 23 instead. Assuming the ATV takes off and docks on time, Discovery would be set for another launch attempt at 4:50:13 p.m. EST on Feb. 24.
If all goes well, NASA hopes to have the shuttle Endeavour ready for launch on its final mission by around April 18. But planning for that flight is somewhat uncertain. Commander Mark Kelly's wife, Rep. Gabrielle Giffords, was shot in the head Saturday in Tucson by a gunman who killed six and wounded 13 others. Giffords remains in critical condition.
At a news briefing Tuesday to discuss the external tank investigation, Bill Gerstenmaier, director of space operations at NASA headquarters in Washington, declined to discuss Kelly's status, saying "out of respect to the family, we really are not ready to answer those questions today."
"We're going to let Mark decide really kind of what he needs to do," Gerstenmaier said. "We'll let his personal situation take focus on his activities and his thoughts and later when we know more about where (the Endeavour mission) sits and what our options are for Mark and his activities, we'll come talk to you at that time. ... Our hearts and prayers go out to the family and we're really thinking about Mark in everything we do."
A drawing illustrates the components of the intertank region on a shuttle's external tank. The top few inches of the vertical stringers, which are pulled inward during fueling by low-temperature contraction, can experience cracks where fasteners attach them to the tank. Credit: NASA
The external tank crack problem first surfaced during fueling for a Nov. 5 launch attempt. Discovery's countdown was called off because of a gaseous hydrogen leak, a problem that was later resolved. But engineers also noticed a large crack in the external tank's foam insulation that developed during fueling. When the foam was removed later, four cracks were found in the "feet" of two adjacent ribs, or stringers, in a compartment that separates the tank's liquid oxygen and hydrogen sections.
The cracks presumably developed when the liquid oxygen tank was loaded with super-cold propellant, causing the flange that supports it to contract, pulling the top few inches of the intertank stringers inward. Tank components are designed to cope with that stress without breaking but for some reason, cracks developed near the tops of two stringers in Discovery's tank.
Engineers were immediately concerned, citing two potentially serious issues. Cracked stringers could result in foam insulation falling off during flight that could pose an impact threat to the shuttle's fragile heat shield. And if enough stringers failed, the structural integrity of the tank could be in question.
NASA launched a wide-ranging investigation to figure out the root cause of the cracks and what might be needed to correct the problem. A full-scale instrumented fueling test was carried out Dec. 17 to precisely map out the stresses acting on the tank during fueling. Discovery then was moved off the pad and back to the Vehicle Assembly Building for additional inspections.
Cracks found on the tank's backside Panel 6. Credit: NASA
Engineers then found four more cracks on the back side of the tank near the tops of three stringers, which could not be inspected at the launch pad. Like the first set of cracks, these were repaired by splicing in fresh stringer segments and attaching doublers for additional strength.
Believing built-in stresses from assembly likely caused the cracks, engineers proposed installing doublers on stringers to either side of massive solid rocket booster attachment panels that experience the most stress during flight.
But as it turned out, the issue was more complicated than first suspected. Engineers reviewing manufacturing records discovered that the aluminum-lithium alloy used in 78 of the 108 stringers in the intertank of Discovery's external tank came from a batch that had a mottled appearance, possibly the result of heat treatments during the alloy's formulation. Testing showed the material used in those stringers had just 65 percent of the expected fracture strength.
On New Year's Eve, Shannon said, engineers successfully re-created a crack using the same mottled aluminum-lithium alloy in a test rig that subjected it to the same sorts of stress the tank experiences during fueling.
Normal aluminum-lithium alloy, using in external tank stringers, is shown in the top sample. Mottled material in the lower sample was used in Discovery's external tank. It has a lower fracture strength. Credit: NASA
"We absolutely have root cause and we have been able to show that through test," he said. "It's a combination of two factors. It's the low fracture toughness of the material, we have about 65 percent of the expected fracture toughness, combined with some assembly stresses that were built up in different areas.
"We know that because when we loaded the tank (with propellant), we put high stress on all of those stringers that had that low fracture toughness and we only had cracks in five of what we believe were 78 stringers. In looking at those stringers that cracked, we're seeing the evidence of those assembly stresses that combined with that low fracture toughness to cause the problem. So we have root cause and we have a fix that we're completely confident will eliminate those root causes."
The fix is installation of radius block plates all the way around the circumference of the upper intertank to beef up the under-strength stringers. The repair calls for engineers to remove the top few rivets holding the sides of each stringer in place. An aluminum plate -- a radius block -- is then placed over the stringer attachment "feet" and riveted into place. The idea is to lock the stringer flat against the side of the tank and make it less susceptible to the stresses that could cause fractures to develop.
NASA's fix calls for bolting so called "radius blocks" over stringer attachment fittings to ensure a flat, tight fit, making them less susceptible to cracking. Credit: NASA
Shannon said engineers are carrying out tests and analyses to make sure the repairs do not introduce any unintended consequences.
"We're proving that out through tests, we're looking at the strain, we're looking at the stiffness and verifying in the tests that material that does not have a radius block does not behave any different than one that does have a radius block," he said. "We're going through and modeling that through the entire tank and verifying we're not going to do any harm. Right now, it looks really good."
The repair work is expected to be completed by around Jan. 23. After that, engineers will move Discovery back to pad 39A for work to ready the ship for launch.
The official embroidered crew patch for shuttle Discovery's final flight is available in our store. Free shipping to U.S. addresses! U.S. SHOPPERS | WORLDWIDE
Additional coverage for subscribers: VIDEO:
ROOT CAUSE OF SHUTTLE TANK CRACKS FOUND PLAY
WORK UNDERWAY TO REMOVE FOAM AND SENSORS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SETTING UP ACCESS PLATFORMS AROUND TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
SHUTTLE ROLLED BACK TO ASSEMBLY BUILDING PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
DISCOVERY DEPARTS LAUNCH PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
LUNAR ECLIPSE OVER DISCOVERY PLAY | HI-DEF
HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE FUELING TEST PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
RECAP OF THE FUELING EXERCISE PLAY VIDEO:
FUELING TEST COUNTDOWN UPDATE PLAY VIDEO:
COMMENTS FROM SHUTTLE LAUNCH DIRECTOR PLAY VIDEO:
GROUND UMBILICAL CARRIER PLATE CHECKED PLAY VIDEO:
INFO ON EXTERNAL TANK INSTRUMENTATION PLAY VIDEO:
DETAILED INFORMATION ON SPECIAL FUELING TEST PLAY
SHUTTLE DISCOVERY'S LAUNCH DELAYED TO FEBRUARY PLAY
FINAL PREPS FOR INSTRUMENTED TEST PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
STRAIN GAUGES ATTACHED TO TANK PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
BACKSCATTER INSPECTIONS OF TANK MIDSECTION PLAY | HI-DEF
INSTALLING DOUBLERS OVER STRINGERS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
GASEOUS HYDROGEN VENT ARM RETURNED PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
DOUBLERS TO BEEF UP CRACKED BEAMS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
HYDROGEN FITTING IS REINSTALLED PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
OPENING UP TANK'S ENTRANCE DOOR PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
GUCP DETACHED AND SEALS REMOVED PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
BROKEN FOAM REMOVED FROM THE TANK PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
VENT ARM LETS GO FROM LEAKY GUCP PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
DISCOVERY AWAITS REPAIRS TO TANK PROBLEMS PLAY | HI-DEF
INFORMATIVE DESCRIPTION OF TANK CRACK PROBLEM PLAY VIDEO:
DISCOVERY'S LAUNCH DELAYED TO MID-DECEMBER PLAY
GASEOUS HYDROGEN VENT ARM DETACHED FROM SHUTTLE PLAY
STS-133 MISSION PREVIEW MOVIE PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SHUTTLE DISCOVERY CREW BIOGRAPHIES PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
ISS EXPEDITION 25-26 PREVIEW MOVIE PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SPACE STATION CREW BIOGRAPHIES PLAY | HI-DEF
POST-SCRUB NEWS BRIEFING ON LEAK PLAY VIDEO:
GASEOUS HYDROGEN LEAK SCRUBS LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
BAD WEATHER DELAYS DISCOVERY LAUNCH PLAY VIDEO:
ELECTRICAL ISSUE NO LONGER A CONCERN FOR DISCOVERY PLAY VIDEO:
LAUNCH POSTPONED BY ELECTRICAL CONCERN PLAY VIDEO:
TUESDAY MORNING'S COUNTDOWN STATUS CHECK PLAY VIDEO:
DISCOVERY'S PRE-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE PLAY VIDEO:
COUNTDOWN PREVIEW BRIEFING AND WEATHER FORECAST PLAY VIDEO:
ANOTHER 24-HOUR DELAY ORDERED TO FINISH REPAIRS PLAY VIDEO:
LAUNCH DELAYED 24 HOURS BY LEAK REPAIRS PLAY
FLIGHT READINESS REVIEW SETS LAUNCH DATE PLAY
SHUTTLE AND STATION PROGRAM BRIEFING PLAY VIDEO:
THE STS-133 MISSION OVERVIEW PRESENTATIONS PLAY VIDEO:
PREVIEW BRIEFING ON MISSION'S SPACEWALKS PLAY VIDEO:
IN-DEPTH BACKGROUND ON ROBONAUT 2 HUMANOID PLAY VIDEO:
THE ASTRONAUTS' PRE-FLIGHT NEWS BRIEFING PLAY
PAYLOAD BAY DOORS CLOSED FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CREW LEAVES KSC FOR TRIP TO HOUSTON PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
ASTRONAUTS INSPECT THE PAYLOAD BAY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SHUTTLE EVACUATION PRACTICE PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
ASTRONAUTS EGRESS SHUTTLE AS SEEN LIVE PLAY VIDEO:
ASTRONAUTS BOARD DISCOVERY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SUN RISES ON LAUNCH PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
LAUNCH DAY REHEARSAL BEGINS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
COMMEMORATIVE WALL SIGNING IN VAB PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CREW BRIEFED ON EMERGENCY PROCEDURES PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
IN SHUTTLE TRAINING AIRCRAFT'S COCKPIT PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
TEST-DRIVING AN EMERGENCY ARMORED TANK PLAY | HI-DEF
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH STEVE LINDSEY PLAY VIDEO:
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH ERIC BOE PLAY VIDEO:
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH AL DREW PLAY VIDEO:
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH TIM KOPRA PLAY VIDEO:
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH MIKE BARRATT PLAY VIDEO:
PRE-LAUNCH INTERVIEW WITH NICOLE STOTT PLAY
PAYLOADS INSTALLED INTO DISCOVERY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
MISSION PAYLOADS ARRIVE AT LAUNCH PAD PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CANISTER HAULING PAYLOADS TURNED UPRIGHT PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
MODULE HOISTED INTO SHIPPING CANISTER PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
WEIGHING NEW SPACE STATION MODULE PLAY | HI-DEF
GANTRY PLACED AROUND DISCOVERY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SHUTTLE ATLANTIS REACHES PAD 39A PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CROWDS WATCH DISCOVERY'S FINAL ROLLOUT PLAY | HI-DEF
SHUTTLE HOISTED FOR ATTACHMENT TO TANK PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CRANE ROTATES THE ORBITER VERTICALLY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
DISCOVERY DEPARTS ITS HANGAR PLAY | HI-DEF
TIME-LAPSE SHOWS DISCOVERY ASCENDING IN VAB PLAY VIDEO:
TIME-LAPSE SHOWS THE MOVE TO ASSEMBLY BUILDING PLAY
DISCOVERY'S MAIDEN FLIGHT: FIRST TRIP TO VAB PLAY VIDEO:
DISCOVERY'S MAIDEN FLIGHT: ROLLOUT TO PAD 39A PLAY VIDEO:
DISCOVERY'S MAIDEN FLIGHT: TEST-FIRING ENGINES PLAY VIDEO:
DISCOVERY'S MAIDEN FLIGHT: ASSORTED VIEWS OF FRF PLAY
THE HISTORY OF SHUTTLE DISCOVERY PLAY VIDEO:
THE HISTORY OF SHUTTLE ENDEAVOUR PLAY VIDEO:
THE HISTORY OF SHUTTLE ATLANTIS PLAY
INSPECTION OF THE MISSION PAYLOADS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
ROBONAUT ARRIVES AT KENNEDY SPACE CENTER PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
SPACE STATION'S SPARE THERMAL RADIATOR PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
BLANKETING LEONARDO WITH INSULATION PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
RACK INSERTED INTO LEONARDO FOR LAUNCH PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
LEONARDO RETURNS FROM ITS PREVIOUS FLIGHT PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
STATION'S SPARE PARTS DEPOT ARRIVES PLAY | HI-DEF
ORBITER'S PAYLOAD BAY CLOSED FOR ROLLOUT PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
ASTRONAUTS VISIT THEIR SPACECRAFT PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
CREW INSPECTS LEONARDO MODULE PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
DISCOVERY RECEIVES ITS MAIN ENGINES PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
FUEL TANK MATED TO SOLID ROCKET BOOSTERS PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
HOISTING FUEL TANK INTO CHECKOUT BAY PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
EXTERNAL FUEL TANK UNLOADED FROM BARGE PLAY | HI-DEF VIDEO:
MISSION'S FUEL TANK ARRIVES AT SPACEPORT PLAY | HI-DEF
The historic first orbital flight by an American is marked by this commemorative patch for John Glenn and Friendship 7. U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE
Final Shuttle Mission Patch
Free shipping to U.S. addresses!
The crew emblem for the final space shuttle mission is available in our store. Get this piece of history! U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE
Celebrate the shuttle program
Free shipping to U.S. addresses!
This special commemorative patch marks the retirement of NASA's Space Shuttle Program. Available in our store! U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE
Anniversary Shuttle Patch
Free shipping to U.S. addresses!
This embroidered patch commemorates the 30th anniversary of the Space Shuttle Program. The design features the space shuttle Columbia's historic maiden flight of April 12, 1981. U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE
Free shipping to U.S. addresses!
Celebrate the 50th anniversary of Alan Shephard's historic Mercury mission with this collectors' item, the official commemorative embroidered patch. U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE
Fallen Heroes Patch Collection
The official patches from Apollo 1, the shuttle Challenger and Columbia crews are available in the store. U.S. STORE WORLDWIDE STORE