Spaceflight Now




Astronauts will inspect shuttle heat shield Wednesday
BY WILLIAM HARWOOD
STORY WRITTEN FOR CBS NEWS "SPACE PLACE" & USED WITH PERMISSION
Posted: September 19, 2006

The Atlantis astronauts will spend their early morning hours Wednesday using the shuttle's robot arm to examine the ship from top to bottom and stem to stern for any signs of damage or missing hardware that might explain the source of a mysterious object that apparently floated away from the orbiter earlier today.

Concern about that object prompted NASA to delay Atlantis' return to Earth by 24 hours, from Wednesday to Thursday, to give the astronauts and engineers time to make sure the ship's heat shield and other critical systems are healthy before committing the ship to a fiery re-entry.

Shuttle Program Manager Wayne Hale said late today he's hopeful whatever the object might be it's not something that poses a threat to the shuttle or its crew. He said it may be something as simple as a plastic shim that shook out from between two tiles during pre-landing tests earlier today.


This series of images from the flight day 3 inspections shows the shim seen on belly of Atlantis. Credit: NASA
 
Such shims are used to make sure adjacent tiles are properly spaced during installation to account for expansion and contraction of the shuttle's aluminum skin during broad temperature swings in space. A piece of shim stock was spotted during a heat shield inspection two days after launch sticking up from between tiles on one of Atlantis' propellant feedline doors.

Whether activation of the shuttle's hydraulic system or jarring test firings of the shuttle maneuvering jets today could have shaken the shim free is not yet known. The shim does not pose any threat to the shuttle, but engineers don't yet know if it is, in fact, what showed up in the downlinked television views. Likewise, it's not yet known whether a second object spotted by commander Brent Jett that was seen floating away from the shuttle shortly after noon is a problem or not.

But Hale said engineers have dismissed earlier concern about eight potential impact "events" detected by wing leading edge sensors. Analysis of timing data shows the sensors were simply responding to vibrations induced by the shuttle's hydraulic system during a routine pre-landing flight control system checkout.

Spaceflight Now Plus
Additional coverage for subscribers:
VIDEO: MID-DAY BRIEFING BY SHUTTLE CHIEF DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: SHUTTLE CAMERA SPOTS MYSTERY OBJECT PLAY
VIDEO: HOUSTON TELLS CREW ABOUT THE OBJECT PLAY
MORE: STS-115 VIDEO COVERAGE
SUBSCRIBE NOW


To make sure Atlantis' heat shield is, in fact, intact, the astronauts will unlimber the shuttle's robot arm for a five-hour overnight inspection. Cameras on the 50-foot-long robot arm should be able to spot any critical damage to the shuttle's wing leading edge panels or heat-shield tiles that's above the threshold need to cause problems.

"This data is not like the very fine, almost microscopic inspections we've done of the (wing leading edge panels) before," Hale said. "We think if this piece came off (the heat shield), this is going to be easy to see. So we can look further back, we can scan faster, we can do it with less delicate sensors. This is a standard television camera and by going down the line at a relatively slow pace you can see right away is there something big missing or is it generally in good shape? This inspection is appropriate for the concern that we might have something like that."

If poor lighting or other problems associated with oblique viewing angles develops, the astronauts will use the arm to pick up a 50-foot-long heat-shield inspection boom for a more thorough inspection or a focused look at a particular area of interest.

If the boom has to be used, the long crew day could prompt NASA to delay re-entry until Friday to make sure the crew has time to rest up after a busy day in space. If no problems are seen during the robot arm survey, Atlantis likely will be cleared for landing Thursday at the Kennedy Space Center.

The shuttle has enough on-board supplies to remain in orbit until Saturday. The weather forecast for Thursday and Friday calls for good conditions at the Kennedy Space Center.

Here is an updated timeline of overnight activity (in EDT and mission elapsed time):


09/19/06
Tue  09:45 PM   10   10   30   Crew wakeup
Tue  11:45 PM   10   12   30   Robot arm survey

09/20/06
Wed  04:45 AM   10   17   30   Crew lunch
Wed  05:45 AM   10   18   30   Orbiter boom sensor system unberth (if needed)
Wed  06:40 AM   10   19   25   OBSS survey (if needed)
Wed  09:55 AM   10   22   40   OBSS berthing (if needed)
Wed  10:30 AM   10   23   15   Robot arm powerdown (if needed)
Wed  01:45 PM   11   02   30   Crew sleep begins
Wed  09:45 PM   11   10   30   Crew wakeup

09/21/06
Thu  05:19 AM   11   18   04   Deorbit burn (orbit 186; if no problems seen)
Thu  06:21 AM   11   19   06   Landing at the Kennedy Space Center
Thu  06:55 AM   11   19   40   Backup deorbit ignition (orbit 187)
Thu  07:57 AM   11   20   42   Backup landing opportunity

"The crew's going to wake up about (9:45 p.m.), we will let them get up and do the normal things they do in post sleep for about two hours, get breakfast, start their day, then we will start a survey of the vehicle with the remote manipulator system cameras that we think will take about five hours.

"The goal of that survey is to get the general sense to make sure we're not missing any large pieces of the thermal protection system. We don't think we are, but this is to make sure. We think at the end of that survey we will be in a very good posture to believe we are good to come home.

"However, we have built an option into the plan that after the crew's lunch period they can get the orbiter boom sensor system out and spend another three hours with that additional boom looking at some hard-to-see areas."

With the OBSS attached to the robot arm, the astronauts have the ability to inspect virtually the entire shuttle, including all areas of the belly that would be of critical concern for re-entry. But the robot arm alone should be able to do the trick, Hale said. Anything large enough to cause problems is well within the detection of the arm's cameras.

The shim stock, for example, was easily visible during Atlantis' final approach to the international space station Sept. 11. Camera views showed the reddish, rectangular piece of plastic sticking up at an angle between tiles on a door used to cover one of two external tank propellant feedline entrances in the belly of the shuttle.

Engineers determined the shim posed no threat to the shuttle and would harmlessly melt or blow off during re-entry. As a result, NASA managers decided to simply leave it in place.

"If we are satisfied at the crew's lunch hour that we have a good inspection and we believe there's nothing untoward, then we won't get the OBSS out and we'll come home normally (Thursday).

"One of the things I think a lot of folks have talked about quite a bit as the most likely candidate is that piece of shim stock that we saw sticking out from the underside of the orbiter ... on flight day three as we approached the international space station. It's very likely the flight control system checkout provided the impetus, the shock, the vibration ... that shook that loose and it floated out. We don't know for sure, but it's a highly likely candidate.

"If, in fact, we go look and that piece of shim stock is missing, we had quite the interesting debate in the Mission Management Team about whether that in itself was sufficient and we could just quit there. The discussion came to the conclusion that no, since we've got the arm out and we can't conclusively prove one way or the other that it was the shim stock, we ought to go complete the survey and make sure we don't see anything else that would cause us any concern."

Engineers do not believe the mystery object was the result of an impact with orbital debris or a micrometeoroid. A high-energy impact would have imparted a higher departure velocity to any debris and other sensors likely would have detected the disturbance.

Engineers also haven't found any signs of unusual temperatures on the shuttle that might otherwise be expected if a thermal blanket or heat-shield tiles were missing.

"We're just doing what I would call due diligence here," Hale said. "We have the capability to remain in orbit until Saturday, we have the tools to go off and make sure we are safe for re-entry so we have no reason, in fact, not to go take a look and put every concern to rest. And that's what the plan is built to do and executing this plan we think we'll have a good feeling about coming home on Thursday."

But if the inspections keep the crew up late, NASA managers may opt to "give them another day on orbit to rest up before the critical entry phase" to make sure "we have a well rested and prepare crew to fly the critical phases of entry and we don't want to do that with folks who are tired or overly concerned about anything. So we're going to put all that to rest."

Here is a list of all the available landing opportunities through Saturday at the Kennedy Space Center, Edwards Air Force Base, Calif., and Northtrup Strip at White Sands, N.M. (all times in EDT):


DATE    ORBIT D/O BURN   LANDING    SITE

09/21   186   05:14 AM   06:22 AM   Kennedy Space Center
09/21   187   06:46 AM   07:54 AM   Northrup Strip
09/21   187   06:50 AM   07:57 AM   KSC
09/21   188   08:20 AM   09:27 AM   Edwards Air Force Base
09/21   188   08:22 AM   09:29 AM   NOR
09/21   189   09:56 AM   11:03 AM   EDW

09/22   201   04:02 AM   05:10 AM   KSC
09/22   202   05:37 AM   06:45 AM   KSC
09/22   203   07:07 AM   08:15 AM   EDW
09/22   203   07:09 AM   08:16 AM   NOR
09/22   204   08:43 AM   09:50 AM   EDW
09/22   204   08:45 AM   09:52 AM   NOR
09/22   205   10:19 AM   11:26 AM   EDW

09/23   217   04:24 AM   05:32 AM   KSC
09/23   218   05:56 AM   07:03 AM   NOR
09/23   218   06:00 AM   07:08 AM   KSC
09/23   219   07:30 AM   08:37 AM   EDW
09/23   219   07:32 AM   08:39 AM   NOR
09/23   220   09:06 AM   10:13 AM   EDW

Spaceflight Now Plus
Additional coverage for subscribers:
VIDEO: SUNDAY'S STATUS BRIEFING DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: STATION BACKDROPPED BY BLACK SPACE PLAY
VIDEO: STATION SLIDES BY EARTH'S HORIZON PLAY
VIDEO: SPACE STATION FLYAROUND BY ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS UNDOCKS FROM THE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: HATCHWAY CLOSED FOR UNDOCKING PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ASTRONAUTS BID FAREWELL PLAY
VIDEO: FLIGHT DIRECTOR EXPLAINS UNDOCKING PLAY

VIDEO: LAUNCH AS SEEN BY HIGH-ALTITUDE WB-57 AIRCRAFT PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: STARBOARD INWARD PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: STARBOARD UPWARD PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: STARBOARD DOWNWARD PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: PORT INWARD PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: PORT UPWARD PLAY
VIDEO: SOLID ROCKET BOOSTER CAM: PORT DOWNWARD PLAY

VIDEO: FIRST SOLAR WING DEPLOYED HALF-WAY PLAY
VIDEO: SECOND SOLAR WING EXTENDED ONE SECTION PLAY
VIDEO: FIRST SOLAR WING EXTENDED ONE SECTION PLAY

VIDEO: POST-EVA 2 STATUS BRIEFING DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: PORT 3/PORT 4 TRUSS KEEL PIN REMOVED AND STOWED PLAY
VIDEO: HELMETCAM OF BURBANK REMOVING SARJ RESTRAINT PLAY
VIDEO: SPACEWALKERS PAUSE FOR PICTURE TIME PLAY
VIDEO: STEVE MACLEAN REPORTS LOST BOLT PLAY
VIDEO: ROTARY JOINT LOCK REMOVED BY SPACEWALKER PLAY
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP PREVIEW OF SPACEWALK NO. 2 PLAY
VIDEO: POST-EVA 1 STATUS BRIEFING DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: TANNER LOSES BOLT DURING ROTARY JOINT WORK PLAY
VIDEO: PIPER UNFOLDS SOLAR BLANKET BOXES SHORT | FULL
VIDEO: SECOND WING'S STRUCTURE DEPLOYED BY PIPER PLAY
VIDEO: FIRST SOLAR WING'S STRUCTURE DEPLOYED BY TANNER PLAY
VIDEO: STEP-BY-STEP PREVIEW OF SPACEWALK NO. 1 PLAY
VIDEO: TRUSS HANDED FROM SHUTTLE ARM TO STATION ARM PLAY
VIDEO: ARM MANEUVERS TRUSS OVER SHUTTLE WING PLAY
VIDEO: TRUSS SLOWLY LIFTED OUT OF PAYLOAD BAY PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS' ARM GRAPPLES THE TRUSS PLAY
VIDEO: MONDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: ATLANTIS WELCOMED ABOARD THE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: DOCKING REPLAY FROM CAMERA ON SHUTTLE ARM PLAY
VIDEO: SHUTTLE ATLANTIS DOCKS TO THE STATION PLAY
VIDEO: ATLANTIS' BREATH-TAKING FLIP MANEUVER PLAY
VIDEO: CREW'S CAMCORDER FOOTAGE OF EXTERNAL TANK PLAY
VIDEO: NARRATED ANIMATION PREVIEWING TRUSS UNBERTHING PLAY
VIDEO: NARRATED ANIMATION PREVIEWING THE DOCKING PLAY
VIDEO: NARRATED ANIMATION OF PAYLOAD BAY CONFIGURATION PLAY
MORE: STS-115 VIDEO COVERAGE
SUBSCRIBE NOW

VIDEO: BRIEFING ON TANK'S PERFORMANCE DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: TANK'S ONBOARD CAMERA LIFTOFF TO SEPARATION PLAY
VIDEO: FLIGHT DIRECTOR EXPLAINS INSPECTIONS PLAY
VIDEO: SUNDAY'S MISSION STATUS BRIEFING DIAL-UP | BROADBAND

VIDEO: LAUNCH OF ATLANTIS! PLAY
VIDEO: SHEDDING FOAM MAY HAVE HIT ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: ONBOARD VIEW OF EXTERNAL TANK SEPARATION PLAY
VIDEO: INSIDE MISSION CONTROL DURING LAUNCH PLAY
VIDEO: STATION CREW TOLD VISITORS EN ROUTE PLAY
VIDEO: HOUSTON RADIOS DEBRIS REPORT TO CREW PLAY
VIDEO: POST-LAUNCH NEWS CONFERENCE DIAL-UP | BROADBAND
VIDEO: QUICK-LOOK BRIEFING ON DEBRIS DIAL-UP | BROADBAND

LAUNCH REPLAYS:
VIDEO: BEACH MOUND TRACKER PLAY
VIDEO: CAMERA IN FRONT OF PAD PLAY
VIDEO: BANANA CREEK VIEWING SITE PLAY
VIDEO: VEHICLE ASSEMBLY BUILDING ROOF PLAY
VIDEO: PAD 39B SIDE PERIMETER PLAY
VIDEO: PLAYALINDA BEACH TRACKER PLAY
VIDEO: PLAYALINDA BEACH ZOOM PLAY
VIDEO: UCS 23 TRACKER PLAY
VIDEO: UCS 11 TRACKER PLAY

VIDEO: MISSION SPECIALIST 4 STEVE MACLEAN BOARDS ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: MISSION SPECIALIST 3 HEIDE PIPER BOARDS PLAY
VIDEO: MISSION SPECIALIST 2 DAN BURBANK BOARDS PLAY
VIDEO: MISSION SPECIALIST 1 JOE TANNER BOARDS PLAY
VIDEO: PILOT CHRIS FERGUSON BOARDS PLAY
VIDEO: COMMANDER BRENT JETT BOARDS PLAY

VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS EMERGE FROM CREW QUARTERS PLAY
VIDEO: CREW SUITS UP FOR LAUNCH TO SPACE PLAY
VIDEO: FINAL INSPECTION TEAM CHECKS ATLANTIS PLAY
VIDEO: ASTRONAUTS READY FOR SECOND LAUNCH TRY PLAY
MORE: STS-115 VIDEO COVERAGE
SUBSCRIBE NOW

STS-115 patch
The official crew patch for the STS-115 mission of space shuttle Atlantis to resume orbital construction of the International Space Station.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide


MISSION INDEX