Spaceflight Now


Critical foam impact test planned for Thursday
BY WILLIAM HARWOOD
STORY WRITTEN FOR CBS NEWS "SPACE PLACE" & USED WITH PERMISSION
Posted: June 4, 2003

Computer analysis and the results of a dramatic test last week indicate a critical experiment on tap Thursday may help investigators determine, to the satisfaction of most, that a foam strike during the shuttle Columbia's launching was the initiating event that led to the ship's destruction. While the root cause will never been known with 100 percent certainty, engineers believe Thursday's experiment could go a long way toward eliminating any lingering doubt about what damaged the leading edge of the shuttle's left wing, creating the breach that ultimately doomed the ship and its crew.


Foam strikes a mockup of the space shuttle wing leading edge system during a test last week. Credit: CAIB
 
"From my perspective, and I'm not speaking for the board now, I think it moves us a lot closer toward a very likely initiating event," said Scott Hubbard, a member of the Columbia Accident Investigation Board overseeing the tests. "I think it establishes foam can break (wing leading edge panels) in a realistic environment and for my own sake, I think it moves us a significant step toward establishing that is an initiating event. There could have been other initiating events, but I think this moves us a lot closer to saying the foam can do this kind of damage."

Columbia was destroyed Feb. 1 by a breach in the leading edge of the ship's left wing that allowed super-heated air to burn its way into the interior. At issue is what caused the breach in the first place. During launch Jan. 16, a large piece of foam insulation broke off Columbia's external fuel tank and slammed into the underside of the left wing's leading edge at some 530 mph. A NASA analysis during the mission concluded the foam might damage heat-shield tiles, but that it wouldn't cause any safety of flight concerns. The analysis all but dismissed any possibility of significant leading edge damage.

Since the accident, engineers have been trying to pin down exactly what sort of damage might actually have been caused such an impact. They have refined their initial estimates of the mass of the foam, based on enhanced photography and computer analysis, and they now believe it struck the leading edge, while rapidly rotating, at an angle of 15 degrees.

During the test last week at the Southwest Research Institute in San Antonio, Texas, a 1.7-pound piece of external fuel tank foam insulation was fired at a mockup of a shuttle wing leading edge by a nitrogen gas canon. The foam, traveling at some 531 mph, struck a Fiberglass leading edge panel, taken from the prototype shuttle Enterprise, at an angle of 20 degrees. The higher angle was chosen to account for rotational energy in the actual impact that cannot be simulated. The Fiberglass panel, mounted in position No. 6, served as a stand in for the reinforced carbon carbon panels actually used on the space shuttle.


The results of last week's foam impact test shows the T-seal moved out of position. Credit: CAIB
 
Fiberglass is 2.5 times tougher than RCC carbon composite material and engineers were surprised by the results. The impact lifted and deformed a so-called T-seal between panels 6 and 7 while generating up to seven times the force computer models had predicted. Nothing broke and there was no direct gas path into the interior of the structure, but the higher-than-expected impact force caught investigators off guard.

"I was standing there and I heard all these assertions about well, this only weighs a pound and a half and (the leading edge) is tough stuff," Hubbard said today. "When the gun fires, there's a blast wave that comes out and you can feel it and then I saw the streak and clearly, something happened. I thought to myself, this is more than I had expected. ... I thought oh my God, this is something! This isn't just a light bounce.

"People's intuitive sense of physics is sometimes way off. You don't feel this can do anything. But you fire this at 500 mph and there you saw it, I really did think oh my God, this is really an impact, this is a significant effect. Then when we actually looked at it and saw things spread apart and all that, that's when it really came home to me what one-half MV squared really means."

He was referring to the formula for computing kinetic energy. While the mass of the foam is low, the velocity is very high and that is the term in the equation that is squared. The impact force delivered by the foam is roughly equivalent to catching a basketball moving at 500 mph.

Hubbard and his team originally planned four foam shots at Fiberglass panel No. 6 before shooting at a real RCC panel taken from the shuttle Discovery that is similar in age to the panels making up Columbia's leading edge. But given the higher-than-expected forces observed during last week's test, engineers have decided to forego any additional shots at panel 6 to make sure they don't inadvertently damage any critical support hardware. Instead, they plan to shoot at Discovery's RCC panel Thursday.

"Because the observed effects, the fact that the peak loads were higher than expected in panel 7, the fact that we deformed permanently the T-seal, the fact that the loads in panel 6 were in some cases a factor of seven higher than anticipated, all led us to believe we probably had learned as much as we needed to and that we should proceed to the RCC," Hubbard said.

Thursday's test will use an identical piece of foam as the one fired last week. The foam will hit at the same velocity and impact angle. Computer models, adjusted with a correction factor to account for the different strengths of Fiberglass and RCC carbon composite material, indicate Thursday's impact will deliver more than enough energy to break the RCC panel.

"Those predictions would say that we have by maybe 70 percent more force than we need to break the RCC," Hubbard said. "Now, whether it actually turns out that way or not, that's why we do the experiment. But the analysts are saying it looks like it'll break it."

If it does, or if it causes any remotely significant damage, investigators will have solid evidence the launch day foam strike could have been the root cause of the Columbia disaster. Not absolute proof, but solid evidence.

Columbia Report
A reproduction of the official accident investigation report into the loss of the space shuttle Columbia and its crew of seven.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Mars Panorama

DISCOUNTED! This 360 degree image was taken by the Mars Pathfinder, which landed on the Red Planet in July 1997. The Sojourner Rover is visible in the image.
 Choose your store:
U.S.

Apollo 11 Mission Report
Apollo 11 - The NASA Mission Reports Vol. 3 is the first comprehensive study of man's first mission to another world is revealed in all of its startling complexity. Includes DVD!
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Rocket DVD
If you've ever watched a launch from Kennedy Space Center, Cape Canaveral, Vandenberg Air Force Base or even Kodiak Island Alaska, there's no better way to describe what you witnessed than with this DVD.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Women Astronauts
Learn about women astronauts,what they do, and how they got to where they are today. Read their story and how attitudes towards women in space changed.
 U.S. STORE
 WORLDWIDE STORE

Hubble Calendar
This remarkable calendar features stunning images of planets, stars, gaseous nebulae, and galaxies captured by NASA's orbiting Hubble Space Telescope.
 U.S. STORE
 U.K. & WORLDWIDE STORE

Get e-mail updates
Sign up for our NewsAlert service and have the latest news in astronomy and space e-mailed direct to your desktop (privacy note: your e-mail address will not be used for any other purpose).
Enter your e-mail address:

Hubble Posters
Stunning posters featuring images from the Hubble Space Telescope and world-renowned astrophotographer David Malin are now available from the Astronomy Now Store.
 U.S. STORE
 U.K. & WORLDWIDE STORE

Earth Calendar
NEW! This amazing 2003 calendar features stunning images of mountain ranges, volcanoes, rivers, and oceans obtained from previous NASA space shuttle missions.
 U.S. STORE
 U.K. & WORLDWIDE STORE

Soviet Space
For the first time ever available in the West. Rocket & Space Corporation Energia: a complete pictorial history of the Soviet/Russian Space Program from 1946 to the present day all in full color. Available from our store.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Viking patch
This embroidered mission patch celebrates NASA's Viking Project which reached the Red Planet in 1976.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Apollo 7 DVD
For 11 days the crew of Apollo 7 fought colds while they put the Apollo spacecraft through a workout, establishing confidence in the machine what would lead directly to the bold decision to send Apollo 8 to the moon just 2 months later.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

Gemini 12
Gemini 12: The NASA Mission Reports covers the voyage of James Lovell and Buzz Aldrin that capped the Gemini program's efforts to prove the technologies and techniques that would be needed for the Apollo Moon landings. Includes CD-ROM.
 Choose your store:
U.S. - U.K. - E.U. - Worldwide

An insider's view of how Apollo flight controllers operated and just what they faced when events were crucial.
 Choose your store:
U.S.


INDEX | PLUS | NEWS ARCHIVE | LAUNCH SCHEDULE
ASTRONOMY NOW | STORE

ADVERTISE

© 2014 Spaceflight Now Inc.